Stop wasting ad spend on traffic you could get for free! Learn how PPC cannibalization affects your SEO performance and how to fix it.
Understanding PPC Cannibalization
If you manage both SEO and PPC, striking the right balance is key to maximizing efficiency and ROI. When paid search campaigns compete with high-performing organic listings, brands end up spending more while gaining little additional traffic.
Why does PPC cannibalization matter?
- Dilutes search performance
- Increases cost-per-click (CPC)
- Reduces overall marketing effectiveness
This guide will help you recognize the warning signs of PPC cannibalization, test its impact, and implement strategies to ensure both channels work together for optimal results.
Signs Your PPC Campaigns Are Cannibalizing Your SEO Rankings
1. Declining Organic Click-Through Rates (CTR)
If your organic rankings remain stable but CTRs are dropping, your paid ads might be stealing traffic from your organic listings. This is especially common when branded or high-ranking keywords are targeted in PPC campaigns.Notably, organic CTR has declined by over 37% on mobile and over 12% on desktop due to paid ads and SERP features.
2. Increased PPC Clicks Without Overall Traffic Growth
If PPC campaigns drive more paid traffic but total website visits remain unchanged, your ads may be diverting clicks that would have otherwise come from organic search. A study found that 50% of PPC ad clicks replace an organic click that would have been free.
How to check this: Use Google Analytics 4 (GA4) Traffic Acquisition Report to compare period-over-period traffic changes by channel.
3. Organic Conversions Declining While Paid Conversions Increase
If paid search conversions are rising but overall conversions remain flat or declining, PPC may be cannibalizing organic conversions rather than expanding your reach.
3 Steps to Prevent PPC from Cannibalizing SEO
1. Audit PPC and SEO Keyword Overlap
Not all overlapping PPC and SEO keywords cause cannibalization, but safeguarding your top-ranking keywords is crucial.
- Exclude top-performing organic keywords from PPC campaigns.
- Filter organic search terms where your website ranks position 1-3, as most clicks go to these pages.
- Cross-reference Google Ads Search Terms Report to identify areas where you’re paying for traffic you’d otherwise get for free.
2. Use Negative Keywords to Exclude Strong SEO Performers
If certain terms already perform well organically, use negative keywords to prevent them from triggering paid ads.
- Apply exact-match negative keywords to avoid cannibalization while still targeting related peripheral phrases in ads.
3. Refine Brand Bidding Strategies and Implement Brand Exclusion Lists
Bidding on branded terms isn’t always necessary since users searching for your brand are already likely to visit your site. 62% of Google Ads spend on branded terms is considered wasteful, as those users would have clicked organic results anyway.
However, bid on branded terms if:
- Competitors target your brand name.
- You want to control messaging on the SERP.
Brand exclusion lists prevent wasteful spending on branded queries where organic listings already dominate. This ensures PPC budgets focus on non-branded, high-intent searches instead of duplicating organic traffic.
Special Considerations for Performance Max (PMax) Campaigns
PMax campaigns use AI-driven automation across multiple Google platforms. However, they can cannibalize SEO traffic due to:
- Broad keyword matching across multiple channels.
- Limited search term transparency, making it hard to detect overlap.
- Competing placements, pushing organic results lower.
How to Reduce PMax Cannibalization
✅ Use account-level negative keywords to exclude high-performing organic keywords.
✅ Optimize asset groups and search themes to avoid overlap with well-ranking organic pages.
Tests to Confirm PPC is Cannibalizing SEO
✅ Run a PPC Pause Test: Pause ad groups for top organic terms and monitor organic traffic changes.
✅ Compare Pre- and Post-Bid Adjustments: Lower PPC bids on high-ranking organic keywords and track performance shifts.
✅ Analyze Assisted Conversions in Google Analytics: Determine if PPC ads drive incremental conversions or merely replace organic ones.
✅ Monitor Organic CTR Changes: Use Google Search Console to track fluctuations before and after PPC campaigns launch.
Aligning PPC and SEO for Maximum ROI
Reducing ad spend where possible and avoiding paying for organic traffic improves marketing efficiency.
🔹 Key Takeaways:
- Use negative keywords to block paid search ads on high-ranking organic terms.
- Audit keyword overlap to prevent unnecessary ad spend.
- Implement brand exclusion lists to avoid branded PPC cannibalization.
A well-coordinated PPC-SEO strategy improves efficiency and maximizes the value of your digital marketing investments.
📢 Need expert help optimizing your PPC and SEO campaigns? 42Works delivers data-driven strategies to boost your ROI. Let’s talk!
FAQs
1️⃣ What is PPC cannibalization in SEO?
PPC cannibalization happens when paid ads compete with high-ranking organic results, leading to wasted ad spend.
2️⃣ How do I know if my PPC ads are hurting my SEO?
Watch for declining organic CTRs, rising PPC clicks without overall traffic growth, and shifts in conversion rates.
3️⃣ Should I bid on keywords I already rank for organically?
Not always—exclude high-ranking keywords from PPC unless competitors are bidding on them.
4️⃣ How can I stop PPC from competing with my organic traffic?
Use negative keywords, refine brand bidding strategies, and conduct PPC pause tests.
5️⃣ Do Performance Max campaigns affect organic traffic?
Yes, PMax often targets branded terms, potentially inflating costs by bidding on traffic you’d get for free.
6️⃣ How do I balance PPC and SEO for better results?
Audit keyword overlap, optimize bid strategies, and align PPC with non-branded, high-intent searches.
